Social media where every emerging quarterback is either anointed as the next superstar or dismissed as a fleeting sensation, a new narrative has surfaced, courtesy of Miami Dolphins wide receiver Tyreek Hill. Known for his lightning speed and past connection with Patrick Mahomes in Kansas City, Hill has sparked conversation by drawing a comparison between Chicago Bears rookie Caleb Williams and his former quarterback, Mahomes.

Creator: Rich Barnes Rich Barnes | Credit: Getty Images

The Comparison

As Caleb Williams took the field for his second preseason game, Tyreek Hill was watching closely. The young quarterback’s performance prompted Hill to take to social media, where he suggested a striking resemblance between Williams and Mahomes. “Caleb Williams so nice he reminds me of……,” Hill wrote on X, leaving fans to fill in the blanks. This wasn’t just any casual observation; it was an endorsement from one of the NFL’s premier receivers who knows Mahomes’ game better than most.

The Play

During the game, Williams showcased a set of skills that had analysts and fans alike drawing parallels to Mahomes. His ability to extend plays with his mobility, his accuracy on off-balance throws, and a particularly impressive cross-body pass to Rome Odunze had all the hallmarks of Mahomes’ signature style. It was as if the Bears had found a younger, perhaps even more agile, version of the Kansas City superstar.

The Reaction

Unsurprisingly, Hill’s comparison ignited a buzz across the NFL community. Some speculated whether this could mark the dawn of a new era, while others urged caution, reminding fans that it’s too early to crown a rookie. Nonetheless, the consensus was that Williams had displayed flashes of the kind of brilliance that has come to define Mahomes’ career—a brilliance Tyreek Hill is all too familiar with.

Creator: Jamie Squire | Credit: Getty Images

The Reality Check

However, it’s important to temper expectations. Comparing any rookie to Patrick Mahomes is a lofty endeavor. While Williams has certainly shown promise, the true test will be in his ability to maintain consistency, demonstrate leadership, and ultimately, win games—perhaps even championships. The comparison may be flattering, but it’s the long-term achievements that will determine whether Williams can truly be mentioned in the same breath as Mahomes.

For more NFL News > NFL News